Amerisleep Organica Plush Mattress Review

In my years as a professional mattress wrangler (yes, that’s a thing), I’ve encountered everything from glorified cardboard boxes to beds so fancy they practically need their own zip code. But the Organica Plush? It’s in a league of its own.

Picture this: layers of natural Talalay latex that cradle you like a gentle giant, organic cotton that breathes softly like a whisper on the wind, and wool that regulates temperature better than your home’s thermostat.

But here’s the million-dollar question (or in this case, the several-thousand-dollar question): Is the Organica Plush the holy grail of eco-luxury sleep, or just another pretty face in the crowded mattress marketplace?

Can it really deliver A-list comfort without leaving an environmental footprint the size of a skyscaper? Can it justify its premium price tag, or will it leave your wallet feeling as flat as a pancake?

Buckle up, eco-warriors and comfort connoisseurs, because we’re about to embark on a journey through every nook and cranny of this green giant. We’ll put it through tests so rigorous, they’d make a drill sergeant weep. We’ll poke, prod, and yes, even sleep on it (tough job, I know) to uncover the truth.

Grab your favorite fair-trade beverage, settle into your most comfortable reading nook, and join me as we unravel the mysteries of the Amerisleep Organica Plush. Because let’s face it, in the quest for the perfect night’s sleep, no stone should be left unturned—especially if that stone is made of organic, ethically sourced materials.

Inside the Organica Plush: Materials and Construction

Diving into the Organica Plush is like peeling back the layers of a decadent organic dessert. This 16-inch hybrid mattress is Amerisleep’s love letter to those who crave an extra dose of softness without sacrificing eco-friendly credentials. As I explored its construction, I was consistently impressed by how it marries plush comfort with sustainable materials.

One thing that impressed me was how the mattress managed to feel plush without being overly warm. The breathable organic materials seem to work overtime to keep things cool and comfortable.

The Organica Plush doesn’t just talk the green talk; it walks the walk. Every component boasts impressive certifications:

• OEKO-TEX® Standard 100
• Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS)
• Rainforest Alliance
• eco-INSTITUT

These certifications aren’t just fancy badges; they’re a testament to Amerisleep’s commitment to your health and the planet’s wellbeing. The fact that it’s handcrafted in the USA adds a cherry on top of this eco-friendly sundae.

Mattress Cover

Enveloping this plush wonder is a cover that feels like it was woven from the softest organic cotton in the realm, at least in my experience.

The GOTS-certified organic cotton isn’t just a treat for your skin, though. It’s a breath of fresh air for your sleep environment. The top is knitted for an extra touch of softness, while the sides are woven for durability.

As someone who battles with allergies, I also appreciated the hypoallergenic nature of this organic cotton. It’s like a fortress against dust mites and other allergens, allowing me to breathe easy (literally) throughout the night. No bouts of daytime sneezing for me!

Wool Fire Barrier

Just beneath the cotton cover lies a 1-inch layer of organic wool. This isn’t your grandmother’s itchy wool sweater; it’s a soft, luxurious layer that serves double duty.

Not only does it act as a natural fire barrier (goodbye, chemical flame retardants and mattress fiberglass!), but it’s also a temperature-regulating marvel. I found it cool to the touch in warm rooms, yet it promised cozy warmth for chilly nights.

Box Top

The star of the Organica Plush show is undoubtedly its 3-inch Natural Latex box top. As I sank my hand into this layer, it felt like I was touching a cloud that had somehow been captured and transformed into a mattress topper.

This additional layer is what sets the Plush apart from its medium-feel sibling, offering an extra dimension of softness that side sleepers and comfort enthusiasts will adore.

Comfort and Transition

Delving deeper, we encounter the Talalay latex layers that form the comfort core of the Organica Plush. There’s a 2-inch soft Talalay latex layer followed by a 1-inch medium-feel Talalay latex layer.

As I pressed into these layers, I was struck by their responsive nature. Unlike memory foam that hugs and holds, this latex had a buoyant quality that contoured without constraining.

The latex felt noticeably cooler than traditional foams, a blessing for hot sleepers like myself. Its open-cell structure seemed to breathe, promising a sleep environment that’s less likely to turn into a sauna overnight.

Coil Support

At the core of the Organica Plush lies an 8-inch pocketed coil system. These aren’t your grandpa’s squeaky springs; they’re individually wrapped coils that move independently.

As I rolled across the mattress, I could feel how these coils provided adaptable support, changing to my body’s contours.

The edge support was particularly impressive. Sitting on the side of the bed, I felt securely supported rather than like I was about to slide off—a common issue with some plush mattresses.

The Finishing Touches

An interesting detail I noticed was the 1-inch wool border around the coil system. While not directly felt, this touch speaks to the thoughtful design, helping the mattress maintain its shape over time.

I also can’t neglect to mention the attached handles along the side, perhaps even more appreciated on this thicker model than on the original Organica. Taking hold of the handles makes it easier to heft and heave the mattress, which makes it easier to slip clean sheets over the bed and give the mattress its regular spin for more even wear.

Finally, the layers of the mattress are held together not by chemical adhesives, but by tufting. This old-school technique enhances durability and aligns perfectly with the mattress’s all-natural ethos.

Testing Sleep Positions

Of course, I can’t just admire a mattress’s materials from afar. No, I’ve got to not only get up close and personal but also put the bed through its paces, spinning and shuffling between every sleep position to see how the Organica Plush performs.

This is the only way I can hope to accurately describe who the mattress is and isn’t suited for, after all. Knowing that there is no such thing as a “one-size-mattress that fits all,” nice as it would be to have a universally comfortable bed.

Overall, I would say that side sleepers will likely find this mattress to be their dream come true, while back sleepers who like a softer touch should also be pleased. Stomach sleepers and those needing extra firm support might want to stick with the original Organica.

Side Sleeping

As a primary side sleeper myself, I approached this test with both excitement and a touch of skepticism. Could the Organica Plush really live up to its name?

Sinking into the Organica Plush on my side was like being cradled by a whipped marshmallow cloud. The 3-inch box top and additional latex layers created a luxurious cushion that allowed my shoulders and hips to sink in just right.

Despite the plushness, I was pleasantly surprised to find that my spine remained well-aligned. The supportive layers beneath the soft top did their job admirably, preventing any “hammocking” effect that lesser soft mattresses have.

Still, I would say that pressure relief is where this model shone as a mattress for side sleeping. The extra give in the top layers provided exceptional padding for my shoulders and hips. I woke up without the usual “pins and needles” feeling I sometimes get with firmer mattresses.

Back Sleeping

As someone who sometimes sleeps on my back, especially when battling the occasional bout of lower back pain, I was curious to see how the Plush version would support this position.

Lying on my back, I felt like I was floating on a supportive cloud. The plush top contoured to my lower back, filling in the lumbar region nicely.

I was particularly impressed by how well the mattress supported my lower back despite its softness. The latex layers and pocketed coils beneath the plush top provided enough pushback to keep my spine in a neutral position.

There was definitely more sinkage compared to the original Organica, but it wasn’t excessive. I felt cradled rather than engulfed, a necessity for a back sleeping mattress.

The Organica Plush could be great for back sleepers who prefer a softer feel and don’t mind a bit more sinkage. It’s especially suitable for lighter to average-weight back sleepers.

Stomach Sleeping

As someone who avoids stomach sleeping like I avoid morning people before coffee, this was the test I approached with the most trepidation. Especially as I know that stomach sleeping and softer mattresses mix like oil and water.

Lying on my stomach, I immediately noticed the extra softness compared to the original Organica. While it felt luxuriously comfortable at first, I did have some concerns.

The plush top allowed my hips to sink in more than is ideal for stomach sleeping. This could potentially lead to lower back strain over time, especially for those carrying more weight in their midsection. A firmer mattress for stomach sleeping might do better.

Still, it’s not all bad. The softer surface didn’t cause any difficulty breathing, which can sometimes be an issue for stomach sleepers on very plush mattresses.

But I would ultimately conclude that the Organica Plush might be too soft for most stomach sleepers, especially those who are average weight or heavier. However, very lightweight stomach sleepers who prefer a softer feel might find it comfortable for short periods.

Combination Sleeping

As someone who occasionally channels my inner rotisserie chicken during the night, I was keen to see how the Organica Plush handled multiple position changes.

Switching positions on the Organica Plush was surprisingly easy despite its softer feel. The responsive latex prevented any feeling of being “stuck” in the mattress. The plush top provided excellent pressure relief for side sleeping, while the supportive layers beneath prevented excessive sinkage when switching to back or stomach positions.

When I rolled towards the edge of the bed, I noticed slightly less edge support compared to the original Organica. However, it was still sufficient to prevent any feeling of roll-off. Still, those combination sleepers who toss and turn might want to keep that in mind.

But overall, I would say the Organica Plush is excellent as a mattress for combination sleepers who prefer a softer feel and spend most of their time between side and back positions. It’s especially good for those who prioritize pressure relief for the shoulders and hips.

How Responsive Is the Mattress?

A responsive mattress makes it easier to change positions during the night. No one wants to feel like they’re sinking into a sponge every time they turn over. For combination sleepers, a responsive bed gives them the freedom to spin like they’re on a cooking spit, freely changing their positions.

Furthermore, a responsive bed is one that is more likely to balance comfort with support, adapting to the body to relieve tension spots while keeping the spine in a neutral position. And as a bonus, a responsive mattress tends to trap less heat, as you sink less into the surface and allow more air to flow around you.

Aside from increasing sleep comfort, a responsive mattress also makes it easier to move out of bed in the morning. When paired with edge support, this can make moving out of bed unassisted more accessible to a disabled person.

I’m pleased to report that the Amerisleep Organica Plush scores an impressive 9 out of 10 for responsiveness. While it doesn’t quite match the perfect 10 of its non-plush sibling, it’s still a top-tier performer.

I relied on the following tests to gauge how the mattress responded:

• The Press and Release Test: This is a simple test, where I just push my hand into the mattress for about 30 seconds. Then I snatch it back, and observe how fast the mattress snaps back into shape. The Organica Plush bounced back in just over a second, slightly slower than the original but still remarkably quick.
• The Bouncing Ball Test: For this test, I take a 10-pound weighted ball and drop it above the mattress. I watch carefully to see how fast and high the ball bounces back, and if it bounces once then settles or if it takes two or even three bounces to stay put. The Organica Plush showed an impressive rebound, with the weight bouncing back about 3.5 inches. This is slightly lower than the original model’s 4-inch bounce but still outperforms many competitors.
• The Sleep Transition Tango: I switched between sleep positions (side, back, stomach) every 30 seconds for 5 minutes. The mattress adapted quickly, allowing for easy transitions without any feeling of lag, though with a touch more resistance than the original model.
• The Sit and Stand Test: I sat on the edge of the bed and then quickly stood up, observing how quickly the mattress regained its shape. The Organica Plush performed admirably, with only a momentary delay compared to its firmer counterpart.

The added 3 inches of soft, natural latex is like a spread of whipped topping that sweetens the surface. While this enhances comfort and pressure relief, it also creates a slightly deeper “hug” that can marginally slow down responsiveness.

The trade-off of more immediate conforming it can make changing positions a tad slower compared to a firmer surface.

But the mattress’s responsiveness is hardly a lost cost, either. It’s just that the plush top absorbs some of the immediate bounce, resulting in a more controlled, gentle rebound. It’s less “sproing” and more “boing,” if that makes sense.

The natural Talalay latex in the comfort layers provides a gentle, buoyant push. It’s a much different feel than the sinkage I might feel on a pillowy soft memory foam mattress.

Instead, I would say it’s like having a team of tiny, silent trampolines working tirelessly beneath you. The pocketed coils beneath the plush layers complete the bed by adding a responsive kick.

How Well Does the Mattress Isolate Motion?

Mattress motion isolation is the sort of thing you don’t think about until you realize how much your current mattress lacks it. For light sleepers or those with restless partners, good motion isolation can mean the difference between a refreshing night’s sleep and feeling like you’ve been through a tumble dryer.

Let’s face it, nobody likes being woken up by their partner’s midnight bathroom runs or early exercise routines. Even if you don’t fully wake up, movement can disrupt your sleep cycles, leading to less restful sleep overall.

Better motion isolation means deeper, more restorative sleep. It helps a mattress suit a wider range of sleepers and situations.

I’m thrilled to report that the Amerisleep Organica Plush scores a perfect 10 out of 10 for motion isolation. While the original Organica model impressed us with a solid 9/10 for motion isolation, the Plush version with its added box top takes things to the next level.

The 3-inch box top adds an additional layer of natural latex, which acts as a motion-absorbing buffer. It’s like having a built-in shock absorber for your sleep surface, more material to dissipate motion before it reaches your sleeping partner. Think of it as a deeper pool—waves don’t travel as far.

This is also a noted benefit to well-made plush beds. Softer materials allow for more immediate motion absorption. Instead of bouncing off a firmer surface, movement is quickly dampened by the thick top layers.

• The Partner Disturbance Test: I lay on the bed trying to sleep (a tough job, I know, but someone has to) while another tester got in and out of bed, changed sleeping positions, and generally acted like a flopping fish that had been tossed onto my bed. I experienced minimal disturbance, even during the most vigorous movements of my companion
• The Human Cannonball Test: Okay, we didn’t actually fire anyone out of a cannon (liability issues, you understand). But I did jump onto the bed while my testing partner lay still with eyes closed. The “sleeping” tester reported feeling more like they were on a gently bobbing boat than experiencing any jarring movement..
• The Work-From-Bed Challenge: In these times of remote work and the temptation of sitting up in bed to do it, this test is more relevant than ever. I worked on a laptop in bed, complete with dramatic sighs and frustrated typing, while the other tried to nap. The “napping” tester reported feeling so isolated from the movement that they actually fell asleep for real.
• The Ball Drop: While it doesn’t come close to what you might see at New Year’s, my team and I drop a couple of 10-pound weighted balls onto the bed from consistent heights, observing how one might disturb the other where it lay. The results were impressive – the impact was barely detectable just a foot away from the drop point.

With its perfect 10/10 score for motion isolation, the Amerisleep Organica Plush isn’t just a mattress; it’s a peace treaty for couples, a sanctuary for light sleepers, and a lighthouse in the fog for those with restless partners.

The plush top doesn’t just add an extra layer of comfort; it creates a cocoon of tranquility that absorbs motion like a sponge soaks up water.

Whether your bedmate is a midnight snacker, an early riser, or practices their dance routines in their sleep, the Organica Plush ensures that their movements stay on their side of the bed.

How Does the Edge Support Hold Up?

Edge support is yet another contender for the title of “most underappreciated aspect of a mattress.” You rarely think about it when it’s there but you definitely take notice when it’s not.

As the term suggests, edge support refers to how reinforced the sides are, how they can bear the extra weight of you sitting or lying down close to the edge. For a couple’s mattress, particularly a smaller one, edge support lets you sprawl out without fear of tilting over the sides.

Even if you sleep alone,edge support can be a must if you have a condition that makes it difficult to move unassisted in the morning. Reinforced sides can make it easier to have that bit of independence by making sure you can safely slide out of bed in the morning.

Plus, good edge support increases how long the mattress will last, as the sturdy sides help the bed hold together down to its center.

While the original Organica model impressed me with a 9/10 for edge support, the Plush version with its added box top takes a slight hit, landing at a still-solid 8/10. This shouldn’t be surprising, though, as it’s common for plusher mattresses to make the trade of lesser edge support for greater cushion.

And indeed, while the 3-inch box top adds an additional layer of soft, natural latex that enhances overall comfort by more immediately conforming to your body, it also creates a slightly less firm edge compared to the original model.

The extra height (16 inches total) also means there’s more mattress to compress at the edges. This can result in a bit more give when sitting or lying near the perimeter.

I didn’t just arrive at this number out of nowhere, of course. No, we subjected the Organica Plush to a series of tests designed to evaluate its edge support in real-world scenarios.

Here’s what we did:

• The Sit Test: I parked my behind on the edge of the mattress like I was waiting for my coffee to brew. The Organica Plush held up well, with only slightly more compression than its non-plush sibling. I didn’t feel like I was about to slide off, which is always a good sign.
• The Lie-and-Roll Test: I lay down right on the edge of the mattress and slowly rolled towards it. This is where many mattresses fail, sending you tumbling to the floor like a log rolling downhill. The Organica Plush performed admirably, allowing me to feel secure even at the very edge, though with a bit more dip than the original model.
• The Stand-and-Compress Test: I stood on the edge of the mattress (I’ve said it before tit bears repeating, don’t try this at home, kids). While there was some compression, it was still minimal. I didn’t sink in like I was standing on a marshmallow, which is more than I can say for some other plush mattresses I’ve tested.
• The Book Reading Test: I sat on the edge of the bed and pretended to read a book for 15 minutes, assessing how comfortable and stable I felt over an extended period. The Organica Plush provided a comfortable seat with only minimal sagging over time.
• The Partner Encroachment Simulation: My partner and I slept on the mattress for a week, with one of us deliberately hogging the bed each night. This test assessed how comfortable and secure the displaced sleeper felt when pushed to the edge. Even when relegated to the mattress borderlands, we felt supported and didn’t fear a midnight tumble.

With its solid 8/10 score for edge support, the Amerisleep Organica Plush proves that you can have your cake and sleep on the edge of it too. The added box top creates a luxurious feel that many will appreciate, and the slight trade-off in edge support is unlikely to be a deal-breaker for most users.

How Long Should the Mattress Last?

While my crystal ball might be a little foggy, my professional opinion is that the Amerisleep Organica Plush is built to last. Its combination of high-quality, durable materials and thoughtful construction suggests that it should provide comfortable, supportive sleep for many years to come.

Here’s a brief overview of the high-quality materials the Organica has:

• The high-grade Talalay latex foam is known for its durability and resilience. The 6-inch top of latex further ensures a plentiful amount of this sturdy material.
• The robust pocketed coil system provides a sturdy foundation that helps maintain the mattress’s shape and support over time.
• The organic cotton cover and wool layers are not only eco-friendly but also known for their durability. In short, the fiber better resist tearing and degradation from their lack of chemical treatments.
• The various certifications (OEKO-TEX®, Rainforest Alliance, eco-INSTITUT) suggest high-quality materials that are likely to stand the test of time and establish a mattress that won’t sag.

Based on all these factors, I’d estimate that with proper care, the Amerisleep Organica Plush could last anywhere from 7 to 10 years, possibly even longer. This puts it on the higher end of the average mattress lifespan.

Of course, several factors could influence this estimate:

• Body Weight: Heavier individuals might see faster wear, particularly in the top comfort layers.
• Sleep Positions: Stomach sleepers might see more rapid wear in the midsection of the mattress.
• Rotation Habits: Regularly rotating your mattress can help distribute wear more evenly, potentially extending its lifespan.
• Use of Mattress Protector: A good mattress protector can shield your Organica Plush from spills, stains, and dust, potentially prolonging its life.
• Environmental Factors: Factors like humidity, temperature, and exposure to direct sunlight can affect a mattress’s lifespan.

It’s also worth noting that Amerisleep offers a 20-year warranty on the Organica Plush. While this doesn’t necessarily mean the mattress will last 20 years, it does suggest the company has confidence in its longevity.

And while the Plush model is new, Amerisleep has a reputation for producing long-lasting mattresses.

Now, I can’t continue without acknowledging that soft mattresses have a bit of a reputation for being “less durable” due to their cushion wearing out. Like a hugged-out stuffed animal that goes flat after you’ve held it tight one too many times.

However, this is where the Organica Plush has an ace up its sleeve: latex foam. Unlike traditional memory foam or polyfoam, latex is incredibly resilient. It’s like the diamond of mattress materials—it can take a lot of pressure and still retain its original shape.

The natural Talalay latex used in the Organica Plush is particularly good at maintaining its structure over time. So while the mattress offers that plush, luxurious feel, it’s not likely to develop permanent body impressions or lose its supportive qualities as quickly as some other soft mattresses might.

Does the Mattress Sleep Cool?

You might have heard it before, but it bears repeating—your body temperature naturally drops as you fall asleep. A cool mattress facilitates this process, potentially helping you fall asleep faster and stay asleep longer.

Overall, cooler sleep environments promote deeper, more restorative sleep stages. It’s like giving your brain the perfect conditions to do its nighttime maintenance.

And as someone who’s woken up in more sweat-soaked sheets than I care to admit, I take a mattress’s cooling ability seriously. The Organica Plush, much like its thinner counterpart, proves that you can have your plush cake and sleep cool on it too.

After putting it through a series of sleep-disrupting tests (the things I do for science!), I’m pleased to report that the Organica Plush scores a solid 9 out of 10 for cooling.

Now, I could bore you with scientific jargon and lab results, but where’s the fun in that? Instead, I put the Organica Plush through a series of real-world, low-tech cooling tests. Here’s what I did:

• The Blanket Burrito Test: I wrapped myself up like a human burrito in a thick blanket and lay on the mattress for 15 minutes. Then, I dramatically unveiled myself to see how quickly the mattress dissipated my body heat. The Organica Plush passed with flying colors, feeling cool to the touch almost immediately.
• The Midnight Snack Run: I went to bed as normal, then set an alarm for 2 AM. When it went off, I got up, walked to the kitchen, had a small glass of water, then returned to bed. The goal? To see how quickly I could get comfortable again without feeling like I was lying on a warm spot. The result? I drifted off to sleep again quickly, with no noticeable warm spot.
• The Partner Heat Test: This one required some cooperation. My partner and I slept on the mattress together for a week, paying attention to how hot we felt, especially in areas where our bodies were in close contact. We both agreed that the Organica Plush performed admirably, with minimal heat buildup even in close-contact areas.
• The Hand Test: Simple but effective. I placed my hand on various parts of the mattress for 30 seconds, then quickly removed it to see how fast the heat dissipated. The Organica Plush cooled down noticeably faster than many other mattresses I’ve tested.
• The Nap Attack: I took a 30-minute nap on the mattress in the middle of a warm afternoon, without any fan or AC. Upon waking, I assessed how sweaty or comfortable I felt. The verdict? I woke up feeling refreshed and notably un-sweaty.

After all these tests, the Organica Plush proved that it can hang with the cool kids. Its 9 out of 10 score for cooling is impressive, especially considering its plush, cushiony nature.

You can sink into pillowy comfort without feeling like you’re sinking into a sauna. It’s a mattress that understands that “hot” should be reserved for your significant other, not your sleep surface.

I thank each part of the mattress for the role it has to play in keeping the bed’s cool:

• The Talalay latex layers are naturally breathable and don’t retain heat like traditional memory foam. It’s like having a built-in air conditioning system.
• The breathable organic cotton cover wicks away moisture, keeping the sleep surface dry and cool. It’s your first line of defense against night sweats.
• The natural wool layer acts as a temperature regulator, keeping you cool in summer and warm in winter. It’s like a weather control system for your bed.
• The coil system promotes airflow through the mattress, preventing heat from getting trapped. Think of it as the ventilation system of your sleep sanctuary.

Remember, though, that “sleeping cool” can be subjective and can depend on factors like your room temperature, bedding, and personal physiology. But I’d say the Organica Plush is a strong choice for those who tend to sleep hot but don’t want to sacrifice plush comfort.

Measuring the Environmental Impact

The Organica Plush represents a balancing act between providing luxury comfort and minimizing environmental impact. While it uses more resources than its slimmer counterpart, it’s still far more eco-friendly than many conventional luxury mattresses.

In my opinion, the mattress sets a standard for what consumers should expect from truly sustainable products. It’s not perfect (no product is), but it’s a significant step in the right direction, backed by some of the most respected names in environmental and health safety standards.

Certified Quality Control

We’ve discussed earlier the certifications that the Organica has, both models:

• OEKO-TEX® Standard 100
• Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS)
• Rainforest Alliance
• eco-INSTITUT

These certifications provide third-party verification of Amerisleep’s environmental claims, offering transparency in an industry often clouded by greenwashing. Together, these certifications cover the entire lifecycle of the mattress, from raw material sourcing to production and eventual use in homes.

Furthermore, many of these certifications require regular audits, encouraging ongoing adherence to and improvement of environmental standards.

I even dare to say that by adhering to these high standards, the Organica Plush helps push the entire industry towards more sustainable practices.

Manufacturing Tidbits

Despite its larger size, the Plush is made using the same zero-emissions manufacturing process as the original. It’s like getting a bigger slice of pie without increasing the size of the pie tin.

Plus, the hand-tufting process used in the Plush model eliminates the need for chemical adhesives. It’s old-school craftsmanship meeting new-school eco-consciousness.

More Materials, Greater Impact?

While the Organica Plush boasts impressive eco-credentials, it’s crucial to address the elephant in the room — or should I say, the extra inches on the natural mattress. Using more materials, even sustainable ones, does come with environmental considerations.

The additional 3-inch latex topper and extra wool and cotton do indeed require more raw materials. This means:

• More rubber trees being tapped
• More sheep being raised for wool
• Larger cotton fields being cultivated

While these are renewable resources, increased demand can lead to expanded production, potentially affecting land use.

However, the plusher, more substantial build could potentially lead to a longer lifespan. A mattress that lasts longer means fewer replacements over time, reducing long-term waste.

The Weight of Comfort

Here’s where it gets interesting. The added mattress weight means potentially more fuel used in shipping. However, Amerisleep’s compression technology still allows for efficient packing, mitigating some of this impact.

They’re proud to say that their methods let them squeeze three mattresses into the space that only one might have occupied in a delivery truck, which can save on fuel consumption by about 80 percent!

Elevating Luxury Expectations

There’s a philosophical question to consider:

• Does creating more luxurious eco-friendly products encourage overall higher consumption?
• Or does it shift luxury consumption towards more sustainable options?

For luxury shoppers who might otherwise choose less eco-friendly options (as many luxury models rely on memory foam and not latex), the Plush serves as a gateway to sustainable sleeping. It’s like sneaking kale into a gourmet smoothie.

And by existing in the luxury space, the Plush challenges other high-end mattress makers to up their eco-game. It’s not just competing on comfort; it’s competing on conscience.

Potential Drawbacks

While this eco-friendly cloud of comfort has a lot going for it, it’s not without its potential pitfalls. After all, one sleeper’s dream can be another’s nightmare.

As we dive into the less-than-rosy aspects of this plush wonder, remember: acknowledging these drawbacks isn’t about bursting bubbles or raining on parades. It’s about giving you, the savvy sleeper, a complete picture.

Because let’s be honest, when you’re investing in a premium mattress like the Organica Plush, you deserve to know both the highs and the lows.

From its cushiony softness that might be too much of a good thing for some, to its imposing height that could turn your bedroom into a mattress museum, we’re about to explore the potential downsides of this green giant.

Adjustment Period

The unique feel of a plush latex hybrid might take some getting used to. Those accustomed to traditional innerspring or memory foam mattresses might need time to adapt. The initial break-in period could even be longer than with firmer mattresses.

Too Soft for Some Sleepers

The plush feel that makes this mattress a dream for side sleepers and those who love a softer surface might be problematic for others:

• Stomach Sleepers: The extra softness may cause excessive hip sinking, potentially leading to lower back pain for stomach sleepers.
• Heavier Individuals: Those weighing over 230 pounds might find they sink too deeply, compromising support and alignment.
• Some Back Sleepers: Back sleepers who prefer a firmer surface for spinal support might find the Plush version too yielding.

Price Point

The Organica Plush, with its additional materials and height, comes at a premium cost. It’s more expensive than many conventional mattresses and even some other eco-friendly options. The cost might be prohibitive for budget-conscious shoppers.

Weight and Maneuverability

At 16 inches tall and with added materials, this mattress is heavier than average. It might be challenging to move or rotate, especially for individuals with limited strength. Furthermore, deep-pocketed sheets are a must, adding to the overall cost.

Too Tall for Some Needs

Even if the plush feel isn’t an obstacle, the added height it creates might be. For shorter individuals or those with mobility issues, it can be a genuine struggle to get in and out of bed. You might need a running start to hop into bed.

In smaller bedrooms, a 16-inch mattress can dominate the space like a slumbering giant. The thick profile can make your bed appear bulky, potentially throwing off your carefully curated bedroom aesthetics. Your bedroom might start to feel more like a mattress showroom.

Allergies and Sensitivities

Despite being hypoallergenic for many, some individuals might have issues. Those with latex allergies should avoid this mattress. Some people might be sensitive to wool, experiencing itching or irritation.

Not Vegan

Latex mattresses can be attractive to those who live a vegan lifestyle, as they’re often cruelty-free in most of their production. The tripping point comes if the latex bed uses wool, as many do to meet fire safety standards.

As with the original Organica model, the Organica Plush relies on organic wool instead of flame retardant chemicals or fiberglass. Those who want a wholly vegan mattress will need to look elsewhere for this reason.

What Other Customers Are Saying

The Organica Plush is still in its infancy, which means comprehensive long-term user reviews are as elusive as a perfect night’s sleep during a heatwave. We’re dealing with a mattress that’s fresher than morning dew, after all.

But while I can’t provide direct user feedback on the Organica Plush just yet, the glowing reviews of the original model paint a promising picture. The Plush version takes everything people love about the Organica and adds an extra layer of luxury.

One prominent example is how Dan from Oneonta, NY, said, “I absolutely love this mattress. It is incredibly comfortable and I sleep really well in it.” Given that the Plush version adds an extra layer of cushioning, we can reasonably expect it to take comfort to the next level.

Based on I experienced on each model, here are some educated guesses about what other users might particularly appreciate:

1. Extra Cushioning: Side sleepers and those who prefer a softer surface are likely to sing the praises of the additional 3-inch box top.
2. Pressure Relief: The extra layer of natural latex should provide enhanced pressure relief, which could be a game-changer for those with joint pain or who simply prefer a more cradling feel.
3. Luxury Feel: Several reviewers of the original model mentioned its hotel-like quality. The Plush version is likely to amp up this luxury factor even further.

Users have raved about the Organica’s green credentials. As one reviewer, Meredith from Washington DC, put it, “I feel good knowing that this mattress is non-toxic and made from sustainable materials.”

The Plush version doubles down on these eco-friendly materials withmore latex foam, so it’s likely to be an even bigger hit with the environmentally conscious crowd.

Many users also praised the original Organica for sleeping cool. The Plush version uses the same breathable materials, so it’s likely to perform just as well, if not better, in this department. My personal experience sleeping on each would suggest they are quite comparable in this department.

As more people experience the Organica Plush, we expect to see reviews praising its enhanced comfort, excellent pressure relief, and eco-friendly credentials.

Of course, only time will tell, but if the original Organica is anything to go by, the Plush version is likely to become a fast favorite among those who prefer a softer, more luxurious sleep surface.

Mattress Policies and Prices

I’ve navigated the fine print of countless sleep contracts like a renowned mattress lawyer, and I can’t stress enough how vital these policies are. They’re not just boring legalese—they’re your ticket to peace of mind and potentially thousands of dollars saved.

Whether you’re a cautious buyer who needs time to commit, a long-term planner worried about durability, or a savvy shopper looking to maximize value, understanding these policies is crucial. They can turn a good mattress into a great investment, or save you from a costly mistake.

Trial

The sleep trial truly puts the power in your hands. It’s like test-driving a car for over three months—plenty of time to really get a feel for how it performs in all conditions.

From the moment your Organica Plush arrives at your doorstep, the clock starts ticking on the 100-nights you have to decide if the bed is “the one.”

Now, I’ll let you in on a little secret from my years of testing: don’t judge a mattress by its first impression. While many folks (myself included) find the Organica Plush to be a dream from night one, your body might need a bit of time to adjust to its proper support.

In my experience, it can take up to a month for your body to fully acclimate to a new sleep surface. So if you feel a twinge here or there in the first few weeks, don’t fret! It’s all part of the process.

Amerisleep understands this, too, and does ask that you give the mattress a fair shake for at least 30 nights before deciding to return it. As someone who’s tested more mattresses than I can count, I can vouch for the wisdom in this approach. It gives you ample time to really settle in and experience the full benefits of the Organica Plush.

But let’s say, after those initial 30 nights, you’re just not feeling the love. No worries! You’ve still got 70 more nights to make up your mind.

If you decide it’s not your perfect match, simply reach out to Amerisleep’s friendly Arizona-based support team. They’ll guide you through the return process, which, I must say, is refreshingly hassle-free.

Whether you’re a side sleeper, back sleeper, or somewhere in between, you’ll have ample opportunity to see how the Organica Plush supports you through various sleep cycles and seasons.

Warranty

Warranties aren’t the most thrilling topic I know, but stick with me. They’re essential to understand as they’re basically the fortress you retreat to when under siege by mattress defects and sagging.

A good warranty is there to save the day if things go south, but hopefully, it’ll just hang in the background, unused but reassuring.

Now, your Organica Plush is protected against:

• Cracks in the latex (we’re talking mattress fissures, not your morning joints).
• Zipper malfunctions (because no one wants a mattress striptease).
• The dreaded mattress valley—any permanent indent deeper than 1.5 inches.

Conversely, don’t expect any sympathy or handholding for the following:

• Normal softening over time. Your mattress is allowed to get comfier, like a well-worn t-shirt.
• Stains, rips, burns, or other damage from improper use. Mattress sumo wrestling? Not covered.

Still, Amerisleep is basically saying, “Take care of your Organica Plush, and we’ll take care of you.” It’s a comfort commitment with a 20-year shelf life.

Though, I must note that 20-year coverage isn’t at the same level the entire time your warranty is valid. See, the first 10 years is the golden era of a full replacement, but for the next 10 years you’ll chip in 50% of the original price for a replacement and cover any shipping and handling charges.

It’s like a mattress co-pay—you’re in it together as a team. And in my experience, this is fairly standard in the mattress industry. Few manufacturers go “here’s a free replacement” once you’ve passed the 10-year mark, as anyone who’s read the fine print on a “lifetime warranty” knows.

Remember, this warranty is like a safety net. It’s great to have, but ideally, you’ll never need to use it. With proper care, your Organica Plush should provide you with years of blissful, cloud-like sleep.

And if you do need to make a claim? Just give Amerisleep a call. Just have your receipt or other proof of purchase ready and be prepared to show some photos of the issue.

Sizes and Prices

When it comes to the Organica Plush, Amerisleep isn’t just offering a mattress. They’re presenting a decadent sleep experience, the bed equivalent of sustainable fine dining.

Comparing it to the original Organica, you might see that the price differs by about $1000 to $2000, depending on the mattress size.

So, what justifies the increased price?

• Additional Materials: That extra 3 inches of natural latex doesn’t come cheap. It’s like adding a built-in luxury topper to an already premium mattress.
• Height: At 16 inches tall, this mattress has a substantial presence. It’s not just a bed; it’s a throne of comfort.
• Craftsmanship: The attention to detail in constructing a mattress of this complexity justifies part of the cost.
• Eco-Luxury: The Organica Plush isn’t just luxurious; it’s sustainably luxurious. You’re paying for comfort and conscience.

Yes, the Organica Plush comes with a higher price tag. It’s a significant step up from the original Organica in both comfort and cost. But for those seeking the pinnacle of eco-friendly luxury in their sleep experience, it’s competitively priced within its class.

That becomes clear when you look at other luxury mattresses like the Helix Midnight Elite, the Purple RestorePlus Hybrid, and the Avocado Luxury Organic Mattress. Beds with similar high concentrations of top-shelf materials, which the Amerisleep Organica Plush still manages to undercut with lower prices.

And remember, a mattress is an investment in your sleep health. If you spend about a third of your life in bed (and if you’re buying a mattress this luxurious, you probably should), the price difference spread over years of use might be worth it for the right sleeper.

In the end, whether any mattress is worth the splurge depends on your priorities, preferences, and pocket depth.

Caring for Your Mattress

Let’s close things out by going over how you’ll want to care of your new mattress. After all, you’re not spending this much money on a bed preparing to take a few precautions and get your full’s money worth.

Now, caring for your Organica Plush isn’t just about maintaining a product; it’s about preserving your sleep sanctuary. With these tips, your plush paradise will continue to provide heavenly sleep for years to come.

Remember, a well-cared-for mattress is a happy mattress. And a happy mattress means happy, well-rested you. Now go forth and pamper that plush – your future self will thank you for it!

P.S. If all else fails and you find yourself struggling with mattress care, just remember: at least you’re not trying to clean a waterbed. Now that’s a whole different ballgame!

The Golden Rule: Protect Your Investment

First things first – let’s talk protection. And no, I don’t mean hiring a burly bodyguard for your bed (though that would be amusing).

No, I mean to invest in a high-quality, waterproof mattress protector. Think of it as a force field against spills, stains, and the occasional breakfast-in-bed mishap.

Pro tip: Look for a protector that’s breathable. Your Organica Plush is designed to keep you cool, so don’t smother it with a plastic-feeling cover.

To complete the effect, I suggest using high-quality sheets. They’re not just for aesthetics; they help protect your mattress from body oils and skin cells.

Wash them regularly. I’m talking weekly, folks. Your mattress will thank you, and so will your nose.

Regular Rotation

Your Organica Plush may be royalty in the mattress world, but even royalty needs to move around sometimes. Rotate your mattress 180 degrees every 3-6 months. It’s like sending your mattress on a mini-vacation to even out the wear.

Mark your calendar or set a phone reminder. Trust me, you’ll forget otherwise. I speak from experience (and a slightly lopsided old mattress).

Cleaning, Because Life Happens

Vacuum the mattress surface gently at least every few months to remove dust and allergens. If you’re like me and prone to sneezing during pollen-heavy times, you might want to vacuum more often to make sure no outdoors debris is settling on the bed and irritating your senses.

Use the upholstery attachment and be careful—we’re pampering here, not punishing. Pay extra attention to seams and crevices. That’s where dust likes to party.

Beyond that bit of touch-up work, you might need to bring out the heavier methods. Because despite your best efforts, spills and stains might occur. Don’t panic—we’ve got this.

For small stains, use a mild detergent mixed with cold water. Dab, don’t rub – we’re not trying to give the mattress a massage here.

Blot the area with a clean, damp cloth to remove soap residue. Let it air dry completely. Patience is a virtue, especially in mattress cleaning.

Airing Out: Let It Breathe

Your Organica Plush needs fresh air too. It’s not high-maintenance; it just appreciates the finer things in life.

Once a season, strip all the bedding and let your mattress breathe for a few hours. If possible, do this on a sunny day and open the windows. It’s like a breath of fresh air for your bed (literally).

The Sniff Test: Trust Your Nose

Occasionally, give your mattress a good sniff, maybe while you’re airing it out. Weird? Maybe. Effective? Absolutely.

A well-maintained Organica Plush should smell neutral or have a faint, pleasant natural scent like vanilla. If you smell something slightly off, like lingering sweat, try sprinkling baking soda over it to deodorize the mattress. Leave it alone and vacuum it all up after a few hours, and that should take care of the smell.

If you notice any unusual odors, it’s time for a deep clean or to check for moisture issues.

The No-No List: What to Avoid

Every relationship has boundaries, and your relationship with your Organica Plush is no different. We’ve gone over what not to do, here’s the overview of what to not do:

• No Jumping: I know it’s tempting, but your mattress is not a trampoline. Save the acrobatics for the gym.
• No Eating in Bed: I get it, midnight snacks are life. But try to resist. Crumbs are the enemy of a clean mattress.
• No Excess Moisture: Keep liquids away. Your Organica Plush prefers to stay dry – it’s not into water sports.
• No Harsh Chemicals: Stick to mild, natural cleaning solutions. Your eco-friendly mattress doesn’t appreciate a chemical bath.

Conclusion

After an exhaustive series of tests that pushed the Amerisleep Organica Plush to its limits, it’s clear that this isn’t just another mattress—it’s a statement piece in the world of eco-luxury sleep.

With an impressive overall score of 9 out of 10, this 16-inch tall wonder stands out as a top contender in the premium mattress market, seamlessly blending sustainability with supreme comfort.

The Organica Plush’s green credentials are more than just marketing speak. However, it’s important to note that no mattress is one-size-fits-all.

The Organica Plush’s softer feel might not be ideal for stomach sleepers or heavier individuals who need firmer support. And while the premium price point is justified by its quality and eco-credentials, it might stretch the budget of some shoppers.

In the end, the Amerisleep Organica Plush is a triumph of eco-friendly design and sleep technology. It’s for those who want to make a statement with their mattress choice – a statement that says, “I care about the environment, but I also really, really like being comfortable.”

Remember, choosing a mattress is a personal journey. If you’re a side sleeper, a fan of plush comfort, or someone who values sustainability and doesn’t mind investing in their sleep, this could be your ticket to nightly nirvana.

Final Score Tally