Best Innerspring Mattress For 2019: Reviews and Buyer’s Guide

While memory foam mattresses have risen in popularity over the last decade or so, many people still prefer the comfort and contouring that an innerspring mattress provides. Today’s top innerspring mattresses manage to deliver the benefits you’re used to, while also improving upon some of the shortcomings associated with springs.

In this mattress review, we’re going to take a closer look at six of the best innerspring mattresses available today. That way, you can find the perfect bed to deliver you the best sleep of your life.

BrandModelHighlightsPrice (Queen)
sweetnight ventilated innerspring mattressSweetnight 10" Hybrid Three inches of pressure-relieving Bio-Pur® foam and clinically-proven zoned support.$460
Zinus iCoil Support Plus MattressZinus iCoil Support Plus MattressGel-infused memory foam to keep you cool and comfortable$297
Vesgantti Innerpsring MattressVesganttiAn eco-friendly latex mattress with great bounce and support.$243
molblly 10Molblly 10” Wrapped CoilFour inches of pressure-relieving hyper-elastic polymer $230
Easeland Innerspring MattressEaseland 10” Hybrid Pillow TopFlippable all-foam mattress for customized comfort.$400
Inofia Pure Comfort HybridInofia Pure Comfort HybridUses copper-infused and gel-infused foams to help keep you cool. $325

1. Sweetnight 10” Hybrid

This innerspring mattress hybrid from Sweetnight is affordable and chock full of features that are typically only available with more expensive mattresses. This mattress offers a sleek, modern look, a luxurious top with a cooling memory foam layer, and individual pocket coils for superior contouring.

A thin top layer of gel memory foam provides cooling comfort while the comfort polyfoam and high-density foam layers beneath offer support. Below the comfort layer, individual pocket coils offer all of the best parts of an innerspring system, without all of the noise and motion transfer. The mattress is medium firm, which most people find quite suitable.

This mattress offers fairly good heat control, and it does a superior job of reducing motion. If you sleep with a partner, you’re sure to appreciate this feature, since you won’t be affected by someone else’s tossing and turning.

These days, most mattress companies offer extensive in-home trials. By comparison, Sweetnight’s sleep trial seems a bit short at only 30 nights. You still have a full month to decide if this mattress is best for you. The manufacturer provides a 10-year warranty on this 10” hybrid innerspring mattress.

Shipping and delivery are easy, as Sweetnight compresses each mattress before shipping. Once your mattress arrives, follow the opening instructions carefully. Your bed will be ready for you that night, although the manufacturer recommends allowing 72-hours for the mattress to expand fully.

2. Zinus iCoil Support Plus

Zinus iCoil SupportIf you have back pain when you sleep or like a firmer mattress, you are sure to enjoy sleeping on the iCoil Support Plus mattress from Zinus. This mattress offers a luxury firm feel, so you avoid that sinking into the bed feeling that many sleepers prefer to avoid in their mattress.

Each mattress features a 2 ½” comfort layer above 7 ½” individual pocket coils. Zinus’s iCoil system provides a firm feel with 10% more coils than the average competitor’s mattress. Despite its firmness, the coils do an impressive job of reducing motion transfer for comfort and stability throughout the night.

The cover of the iCoil mattress is also worth noting, as it’s infused with active charcoal and green tea extract. The cover helps control odors and keep your bed feeling fresh. It’s difficult to say if this feature makes a difference, but it’s interesting, at the least. Quality materials are used throughout the mattress, and the foam layers have CertiPUR-US certification. Zinus also uses a foam blend in the comfort layer that replaces some of the petroleum with plant oils.

Zinus provides a 100-night in-home sleep trial, allowing you plenty of time to decide if the iCoil is the right mattress for you. The company also backs the bed with a limited 10-year warranty. Shipping and delivery are simple, and your new mattress arrives at you in a (relatively) small box.

3. Vesgantti 9.5”

Vesgantti Innerspring MattressThis affordable mattress from Vesgantti provides the best of both memory foam and innerspring mattresses, thanks to its multiple memory foam comfort layers above individual pocket coils. Despite the low price, Vesgantti still manages to provide a luxurious cover, CertiPUR-US foams, and even free delivery.

The comfort layer provides effective contouring thanks to the cooling memory foam top, but it still resists the feeling that you’re sinking into the bed. This 9.5” innerspring mattress is medium-firm, which should suit you regardless of your favorite sleeping position.

Below the comfort layer sits hundreds of individual pocket coils that provide further contouring and support, which helps to relieve back and neck pain. The steel coils are quiet, and between the pocketed design and the multi-layer foam top, this mattress does an impressive job of reducing noise and motion transfer throughout the night.

If you’re indecisive, you’ll be happy to know that this mattress carries a 100-night trial period for you to evaluate the bed. If you’re unhappy for any reason, you can return the mattress for a full refund. While most people replace their innerspring mattress within 5-7 years, this one carries a solid ten-year warranty, so you’ll be covered should anything go wrong.

4. Molblly 10” Wrapped Coil Hybrid Mattress

Molblly 10 Wrapped CoilMolblly is a new mattress company that’s looking to change how the world looks at mattresses that cost under $300. Not only does this pocket coil hybrid provide comfort and durability, but it also offers an impressive suite of foam technologies and fantastic edge support.

At the heart of the mattress are hundreds of tempered-steel coils, which provide the responsive feel that you’d expect from a quality innerspring mattress. Above the coils sits a comfort layer that’s made up of five individual layers. Underneath the coils, additional foam layers provide further motion and noise control. This affordable mattress is one of the quietest you’ll find.

CertiPUR-US, ISPA, and Oeko-Tex Standard 100 all certify the foam in this mattress. You won’t find any harmful chemicals or irritants in the makeup of this mattress, and it’s also incredibly low in VOCs.

Each foam layer works in concert with the other layers, and the proprietary S.T. foam top layer offers temperature control, and a plush feel without losing the responsiveness of the springs below.

While Molblly offers a ten-year warranty on their mattresses, there’s no mention of an in-home trial on their website, or Amazon product pages. So, if you’re wondering if the low price point of this mattress makes it too good to be true, that may be the caveat. If you’re concerned with the trial period (or lack thereof), you should first contact the manufacturer before you buy it.

5. Easeland 10” Hybrid Pillow Top

Easeland Innerspring MattressFor a luxury feel and superior motion isolation, sleepers may want to take a closer look at this pillow top hybrid from Easeland. This medium-firm mattress should be suitable whether you’re a back sleeper, side sleeper, or stomach sleeper, and the plush 3” pillow top provides a luxurious level of comfort.

The pillow top provides three layers of foam, including a layer of cooling gel foam. Below that, layers of support foam sit atop the individual pocket 7 ¾” coils. The multiple foam layers provide superior motion isolation, but the large coils ensure that this mattress doesn’t lose the traditional spring feel.

The pillow top offers a bamboo-infused cover, which provides superior breathability, allowing you to regulate your temperature throughout the night. While the thick pillow top may leave you with questions about this mattress’ pressure relief, it does a stable job in that category.

Easeland appears to be an online-exclusive brand, and no retailers make mention of an in-home trial period. However, if you purchase the mattress from Amazon, it is backed by their customer service guarantees. So, you shouldn’t have any problems getting a return if it’s necessary. The company does offer a standard ten-year warranty.

6. Inofia Pure Comfort Hybrid

Inofica Pure Comfort Innerspring MattressRounding out our selection of top innerspring mattresses is this pocket coil hybrid from Inofia, which provides high-end features, an industry-leading sleep trial, and an affordable price to boot.

This mattress provides a pressure-relieving memory foam layer followed by a layer of foam with a specially designed airflow system to help you regulate your temperature. A thin cooling fiber layer rounds out the comfort section of the mattress. All of the foams in this mattress are CertiPUR-US compliant.

Below the foam, hundreds of pocketed coils help provide support and contouring without sacrificing motion or noise isolation. The cooling cover works to promote airflow, helping to keep you cool throughout the night.

Inofia covers its customers with a comprehensive 101-night in-home trial period. So, you can decide if the mattress is a good fit for you for more than three months before you need to decide. Like the other mattresses on our list, a ten-year warranty covers you in the event of defects.

Benefits of an Innerspring Mattress

When looking for the best mattress, you are going to see plenty about memory foam mattresses, as well as latex mattresses and hybrids. But innerspring beds are still one of the most popular choices. It is probably because there are plenty of benefits to purchasing an innerspring mattress.

Sleeps Cool

If you were able to see inside an innerspring mattress, you’d see that roughly ½ of the space within the mattress is air. This design allows air to flow throughout the bed through the night, keeping you fresh in the process. The layers of foam in a memory foam mattress don’t allow for much breathability or airflow.

With memory foam mattresses, the entire surface of the bed is closed and allows for hardly any airflow. Most mattress brands are quick to point out that their memory foam mattresses offer features like cooling gel tops and moisture-wicking mattress covers. But the fact is that an innerspring mattress will sleep more chill than a memory foam mattress.

Better Edge Support

Since innerspring mattresses feature a rigid internal structure, they tend to provide far superior edge support when compared to a memory foam mattress. This characteristic is essential for people who sit on their bed, as well as for people who sleep towards the edge of the bed.

With a memory foam mattress, you tend to get the feeling that you’re sliding off the edge of the mattress when you’re sleeping close to the edge, or when you’re sitting on the bed. This feeling occurs because the sides of a memory foam mattress don’t have the structural integrity to accommodate your body weight when you’re at the edge of the mattress.

While some innerspring mattresses provide better edge support than others do, virtually all of them offer more support than what you’ll find from a memory foam mattress.

No Off-Gassing

Off-gassing is the unpleasant odor that a new memory foam mattress releases as it adjusts to its environment. The foam these mattresses are made from coupled with the method they’re packaged causes an unpleasant odor that may persist for weeks after you unpack the mattress.

While the gasses released during this process are entirely safe and non-toxic, the smell is unpleasant. People who are particularly sensitive to smell find that memory foam mattresses carry an odor for several months or longer.

Manufacturers make innerspring mattresses from different materials, and they aren’t subject to the same packaging methods as memory foam options. For this reason, off-gassing isn’t an issue with innerspring mattresses.

Hybrid Technology

Many of today’s most popular innerspring mattresses take a “best of both worlds” approach to construction. These beds incorporate coils as well as memory foam into their beds.

Hybrid mattresses feature a comfort layer of memory foam above the coil layer. This design provides you with the superior airflow and responsiveness of a coil mattress without sacrificing the comfort and pressure relief of memory foam.

Hybrid mattresses are a great choice for most sleepers because they allow you to enjoy the benefits of each type of bed without having to deal with the negatives associated with each style. Plus, if you’re looking for the best mattress for side sleepers, consider a hybrid over a traditional innerspring as a hybrid comes with more cushion for your hips and shoulders.

Types of Coil

Mattress companies use several different styles of coil to make mattresses with a variety of characteristics. The thickness of a coil, or the coil gauge, help determine how strong and supportive a coil will be, with most measuring in between 12-15 gauge.

Bonnell Coils

The original coil, Bonnell’s are still a popular coil type thanks to their durability and affordable price.

Most manufacturers make their coils from tempered steel, and each coil is shaped like an hourglass. Each coil links together with helical wires, and they’re usually further reinforced with low-gauge wire. The result is a mattress coil that’s exceptionally durable and able to withstand years of use.

While these mattresses typically aren’t as comfortable as other types, their durability makes them a popular choice for places like college dorms, hotels, and nursing homes. If you’re looking for a mattress that you’ll be sleeping on each night for several years, you’ll probably want to avoid the traditional Bonnell coil mattress.

Offset Coils

Offset coils are quite similar to Bonnell coils in the sense that they feature hourglass-shaped coils that are linked together with helical wire. The bottom of each coil is straightened, which creates a hinging effect when you lie on the mattress and compress the coil.

Similarly, double offset coils are straightened at the top and bottom, which creates an even greater hinging action. This action translates to greater comfort without sacrificing the bouncy feel of the mattress, which is an advantage over Bonnell coils. Offset coil mattresses tend to be quite expensive since they’re the most durable of all innerspring mattresses.

Continuous Coils

Continuous wire coil mattresses are made with several rows of singular wires that are joined together with low-gauge wire. With this style of construction, the springs inside aren’t coils at all.

This style offers comparable durability to offset coils. But, they aren’t known for being particularly comfortable. These mattresses don’t contour to the body well, and they provide little in the way of comfort and support.

Continuous coil mattresses are affordable and make a solid choice for guest rooms, vacation homes, and other areas where they won’t see much use. But, if you’re looking for a mattress that can provide a great night’s sleep for years to come, you may be better off searching elsewhere.

Pocketed Coils

Detractors of innerspring mattresses have always complained that these mattresses don’t provide the same contouring as a memory foam mattress, and they transfer motion far too easily. Mattress companies have developed a pocket coil system to address these issues.

With this style, each coil is individually encased in fabric, and the individual coils are joined together with hot glue instead of helical wire. By using pocket coils, mattress companies can improve the contouring effect of the mattress while also significantly reducing motion transfer. Occasionally, manufacturers refer to pocket coils as Marshall coils.

These mattresses tend to be the most comfortable of all innerspring mattresses, but they are also usually the most expensive. As manufacturers continue to refine their processes and make their beds more affordable, consumers are now able to enjoy the quality and comfort of a pocketed coil mattress without breaking the bank.

Microcoils

Occasionally, you’ll see mattresses that advertise microcoils. Microcoils are precisely what they sound like: miniature versions of full-size coils. Unlike traditional coils, which give a mattress it’s structure and support, microcoils are used in the comfort layer of the bed to provide a plush, responsive feel. While mattresses with microcoils are rare, some people prefer the especially bouncy response they provide.

What to Look for in an Innerspring Mattress

When shopping for an innerspring mattress, there are a few critical features you’ll want to consider before deciding on a bed.

Mattress Top

One of the most important things to consider is whether you prefer a classic tight top or a pillow top.

With a tight top mattress, there’s no additional support layer above the top of the mattress. If you prefer a mattress that’s firm, there’s a good chance you’ll prefer a bed with a tight top.

Meanwhile, if you prefer a softer and plusher sleeping experience, a pillow top is likely the right choice for you. Mattresses that feature a pillow top have a soft, pillow-like layer stitched to the top of the bed. Even if the mattress itself is quite firm, a pillow top will give it a softer feel.

In your search, you’ll also come across mattresses that feature a Euro-top. Euro top mattresses are quite similar to pillow tops, and in many cases, the two terms are used interchangeably. But, there is a difference between the two. Euro top mattresses feature an even softer and more luxurious top layer than what you’ll find in a pillow top mattress. Euro top mattresses are ideal for sleepers looking for the most luxurious sleep experience.

Firmness

Depending on the position you prefer to sleep in, and other personal preferences, you’re sure to have an opinion on the firmness level of your mattress. Some people prefer an exceptionally soft mattress, while others like a mattress that’s stiff as a board. Meanwhile, many more people lie somewhere in between and search for a bed that’s not too soft or too firm.

Some people argue that a firm mattress is advisable for people with back or neck pain, while others say the exact opposite. As you’d imagine, it’s hard to get an accurate idea of what’s best when it comes to firmness.

That’s why your best bet is to decide for yourself. If possible, spend some time trying out mattresses that run the gamut of firmness so you can develop a better idea of how firm you’d like your next bed to be.

Coil Count

Coil count is another essential factor to consider when evaluating a mattress, but not necessarily for the reasons you may be thinking.

Most mattresses feature at least 400 coils per mattress, but some companies advertise that they use well over 1,000 coils per bed. Most people equate more coils with more comfortable sleep, but that isn’t necessarily the case. There’s no evidence to support the idea that a higher number of coils provide better sleep, but mattress companies will undoubtedly charge you as if there is.

As a rule of thumb, a queen mattress should have 400 or more coils. From there, let your body decide which is most comfortable for you.

In-Home Trial

As more companies compete for your money, manufacturers have become increasingly more accommodating to consumers. In the past, you’d buy your new mattress and hope for the best. But today, most manufacturers offer lengthy in-home trial periods so you can decide if the mattress is right for you. If it’s not, you’ll be able to return it for a full refund.

Many top manufacturers offer in-home trials of at least thirty days, with some offering 100-night or more extended trial periods. These trial periods are the perfect way for you to decide whether a mattress is going to be a good fit for you.

Warranty Length

How long the manufacturer warrants your new mattress is another critical component that should influence your buying decision. Most manufacturers stand behind their mattresses with warranties that last ten years or longer, which far exceeds the average lifespan of a bed.

Most people replace their innerspring mattress within 5-10 years, but it’s still nice to have the peace of mind that comes with knowing you’re covered should you experience a defect or other issue with your mattress.

Also, if this is your first mattress purchase, be advised that the warranty policies of mattress companies are notoriously difficult to understand. Each warranty will provide clear stipulations that can void the warranty, and it may be difficult for you to file a warranty claim if you believe your mattress is genuinely defective.

If the warranty your mattress comes with is particularly important to you, take some time to research the different terms associated with each bed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Whether this is your first mattress purchase or your tenth, people tend to have the same typical questions when it comes to selecting the best innerspring mattress. Here are the answers.

Do Innerspring Mattresses Need a Box Spring?

For decades, box springs were the industry-standard base for an innerspring mattress. A box spring has a wooden or metal frame with springs in the middle to provide shock absorption. Box springs provide height, and they help to prevent your mattress from sagging.

But, you don’t necessarily need a box spring, and more consumers are turning to alternative platforms instead. Instead of a boxspring, many people opt for a platform or slatted base. You can also use an adjustable base instead of a box spring with most mattresses on the market.

Whether or not you choose to use a boxspring is mostly a matter of personal preference. But, you shouldn’t feel obligated to use one with your mattress if you’d prefer not to.

How Can I Prolong the Life of an Innerspring Mattress?

The average innerspring mattress lasts between five and ten years, but there are some things you can do to prolong its lifespan.

First, clean your mattress regularly to remove any dirt, dust, and debris from the surface. You should also consider adding a waterproof mattress cover to protect your mattress from damage, like spills or pet accidents. Wash your mattress cover each time you wash the sheets to ensure that the cover itself is clean, too.

Rotate your mattress every six months to ensure that it doesn’t wear prematurely. Some innerspring mattresses can be flipped over, which can further prolong the life of the bed. But, many new innerspring mattresses and hybrids have a defined top and bottom side, so you can’t flip them. If you can, flip your mattress yearly. Otherwise, just rotate it.

You should also inspect your box spring or foundation occasionally to ensure that it’s structurally sound and supportive. Just like a sturdy building needs a solid foundation, a mattress needs a base with structural integrity to offer support. If your foundation lacks support, adding a large piece of plywood cut to the dimensions of your bed can be a cheap fix that can help you get some more time out of your bed before you need to replace it.

If your mattress is getting towards the end of its useful life, you can squeeze some more time out of it by adding a mattress topper. While a mattress topper won’t solve all the problems with your old mattress, it should provide a notable improvement.

Are Hybrid Innerspring Mattresses Better Than Traditional Ones?

While this is a matter of personal preference, many customers are turning to hybrid innerspring mattresses over the more traditional varieties. As mattress technology advances, manufacturers have access to new materials and construction processes that have made way for more comfortable beds.

In fact, there’s very little that separates the two types of mattresses. The only real difference between the two is the material the comfort layer is made from. With a hybrid mattress, the comfort layer is made up of memory foam, and that foam can be infused with a variety of materials, such as graphite, copper, or cooling gel. Meanwhile, traditional innerspring mattresses use traditional padding or down in their comfort layer.

One of the significant benefits of hybrid innerspring mattresses is that they transfer less motion than traditional innerspring, and they provide a level of pressure relief and contouring that traditional mattresses have difficulty achieving. If that sounds good to you, you’ll likely be better served with a hybrid mattress. Of course, there’s something to be said for the tried and true comfort of a classic innerspring.

The best way to decide which you prefer is to try both!

Conclusion

Selecting a new mattress is a significant decision that you shouldn’t take lightly. Thankfully, there are tons of great options to choose from. Plus, with more businesses than ever competing for your business, high-quality mattresses are more affordable today than they’ve ever been in the past.

While some people have been swept up by the popularity of memory foam mattresses, many still prefer the classic comfort of innerspring beds. Each of the six mattresses above represents an excellent choice for your next bed.

Be sure to evaluate each mattress based on the criteria we mentioned above. That way, you can be sure to find the best mattress for your needs.

Medical Disclaimer: The information contained on the site should not be used as a substitute for the advice of an appropriately qualified and licensed physician or other health care provider. The information provided here is for informational purposes only.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top