• Best Mattress
    • Types

    • Best Memory Foam Mattress
    • Best Mattress in a Box
    • Best Hybrid Mattress
    • Best Latex Mattress
    • Best Mattresses Without Fiberglass
    • Position

    • Best Mattress for Side Sleepers
    • Best Mattress for Stomach Sleepers
    • Best Mattress for Back Pain
    • Best Mattress for Combination Sleepers
    • Price

    • Best Mattress Under $500
    • Best Mattress Under $1000
    • Best Mattress Under $2000
    • Size

    • Best Twin Size Mattress
    • Best Twin XL Size Mattress
    • Best Full Size Mattress
    • Best Queen Size Mattress
    • Best King Size Mattress
    • Best California King Size Mattress
  • Mattress Reviews
  • Mattress Resources
  • Bedding
  • Sleep Tips
  • Sleep Research
Home / Mattress Comparison / Firm vs. Soft Mattress — Your Ultimate Guide
Mattress Comparison

Firm vs. Soft Mattress — Your Ultimate Guide

by Amy Murphy Comment on Firm vs. Soft Mattress — Your Ultimate Guide
Updated May 27, 2023

Mattresses come in a range of different firmness levels. Determining which firmness level is best for your body type and sleeping position will ensure you get a restful night’s sleep.

In this post, we’ll discuss the impact that mattress firmness has on sleep and look at the differences between mattress firmness levels. We’ll also examine the benefits of each mattress firmness level for different sleep needs.

Difference Between a Firm and Soft Mattress

Firm mattresses have very little bounce and are designed to give maximum support with no “cushy” feeling. Soft mattresses have plenty of give, allowing them to conform to your body and sleeping position.

One misconception about soft mattresses is that they aren’t as supportive as firm ones. A softer mattress can be just as supportive as a firm one. Soft mattresses get their support from added layers and targeted technologies. Some soft mattress manufacturers include an extra transition layer within their bed, or they’ll go the extra mile and include a surface modification layer—a layer of foam with zoned cutouts to provide full-body support.

Firm Mattress Facts

A firm mattress provides sleepers with a sturdy sleeping surface with relatively little give or bounce. The stability of a firm mattress makes it an ideal choice for sleepers who need extra support and even weight distribution while they sleep. These factors are what make firm mattresses great for back and stomach sleepers.

Benefits of a Firm Mattress

  • Can improve posture/spinal alignment: The dense, semi-rigid feeling of a firm mattress helps encourage better spinal alignment. A firmer mattress improves posture and spinal alignment by keeping your hips lifted while you sleep, and this also alleviates pressure on your spine.
  • Keeps you cooler: A firmer mattress can keep you cooler at night by keeping you more lifted “on top of” the mattress, rather than cradled within. This lifting feeling allows for improved airflow across the surface of your mattress.
  • Improved circulation: Firm mattresses promote better circulation by encouraging better sleep postures.

Best Firm Mattress: Amerisleep AS2

Amerisleep’s AS2 mattress has a medium-firm feel with targeted back support. It’s excellent for back sleepers and suitable for stomach sleepers. The AS2 is also available as a hybrid mattress, for those who like a bed with some bounce.

Warranty

20 Years

Sleep Trial

100 Nights

Shipping

Free

Best mattress features

  • Bio-Pur® foam conforms to the body without feeling overly soft.

  • HIVE® technology ensures back support and increases shoulder and hip pressure relief.

  • Bio-Core® foam supports the mattress and promotes its medium-firm feel.

Recommended for...

  • Back sleepers looking for a firm mattress that’s not too firm.

  • Stomach sleepers looking for a mattress that minimizes sinkage.

  • Plus-size sleepers seeking a mattress that can take on their bodyweight.

Save $300 on the Amerisleep AS2 with our discount code.

Claim Deal

Get resources for better sleep

Sign up for sleep health education, expert tips, and the latest and greatest mattress sales.

See Privacy Policy

Soft Mattress Facts

Soft mattresses are designed to provide sleepers with ample cushion and a plush feeling.

The cradling feeling that a soft mattress provides makes it ideal for those who sleep on their side. A contouring design like this will help sleepers to avoid stiffness or a build-up of pressure in the joints.

Benefits of a Soft Mattress

  • Can decrease joint pain and pressure points: The plush and cushy feeling that is provided by a soft mattress is great for soothing joint pain and relaxing pressure points.
  • Offers “hug-like” cradling: Soft mattresses allow you to compress into the comfort layer and experience deeper contouring.

Best Soft Mattress: Amerisleep AS5

The Amerisleep AS5 is the softest mattress the company offers, standing a full 14 inches tall. It cradles the body with its relaxing plush cushion. Like the AS2, the AS5 mattress has a responsive hybrid counterpart.

Warranty

20 Years

Sleep Trial

100 Nights

Shipping

Free

Best mattress features

  • Thick cushion of plant-based memory foam for eco-friendly comfort.

  • Five zones of support buoy the body and increase pressure relief.

  • Active Flex layer minimizes sinkage that causes discomfort and misalignment.

Recommended for...

  • Side sleepers seeking a plush mattress for pressure relief.

  • Petite sleepers looking for a conforming mattress to unlock full-body pressure relief.

  • Heavier sleepers looking for a soft mattress with numerous support features.

Save $300 on the Amerisleep AS5 with our discount code.

Claim Deal

Factors That Influence Your Ideal Mattress Firmness Level

Sleep Position

Your sleep position will have a significant impact on the firmness level you choose for your mattress. Here are mattress firmness recommendations based on your sleep position:

  • Combination Sleeper: These individuals will be best suited with a medium mattress because they blend cushion and support to accommodate most sleep positions and body types. The best mattresses for combination sleepers are medium because they offer the perfect level of support in conjunction with some body contouring.
  • Back Sleeper: It is key for those who sleep on their backs to keep their spine in a neutral position while sleeping. That’s why back sleepers need a firm mattress that keeps the body lifted. Mattresses for back sleepers are typically medium to medium-firm.
  • Stomach Sleeper: Those who sleep on their stomachs will need extra support for their back, shoulders, and neck. Therefore, the best mattresses for stomach sleepers are firm.
  • Side Sleeper: If you sleep on your side, you’ll need a mattress that provides an adequate level of comfort for your shoulders and hips. In most cases, the right mattresses for side sleepers are soft to medium.

Body Type

Your body type will also influence which mattress firmness level you find to be most comfortable. Petite sleepers will need different levels of comfort and support than those over 250 pounds.

  • Lightweight Sleepers: Smaller framed sleepers and those who weigh 130 pounds or less need a softer mattress to experience adequate contouring and pressure relief. Mattresses for lightweight sleepers should be soft to medium.
  • Heavy Sleepers: Those with larger/longer frames or who weigh more than 230 pounds typically want a firmer mattress to stay in a comfortable position and avoid uncomfortable sinkage. In most cases, the best mattresses for heavier individuals are medium-firm.

FAQs

Can mattress firmness deteriorate over time?

Yes, mattress firmness will deteriorate over time. Most mattresses last between 7 and 10 years, so they may start to sag after 5+ years of use. That is why it is recommended that you replace your mattress every decade or so.

Is it possible for a mattress to be too soft or too firm?

Definitely! Each individual person has a different comfort level when it comes to mattress firmness. A mattress that is too firm can leave you feeling like you’re sleeping on a rigid surface, without adequate support. In contrast, a mattress that is too soft may have a sinking feeling and cause you to wake up feeling stiff the next morning.

If you current mattress is too firm or too soft, you can adjust your mattress firmness using a high-quality mattress topper.

Which mattress is best for back pain?

The best mattresses for back pain are medium-firm. Too firm of a mattress could cause joint or muscle issues. Side sleepers who have back pain will be most comfortable with a medium mattress while those who need a little more support will prefer the medium-firm option. This mattress firmness level will also promote a neutral spine position, which will decrease back pain at night.

Which mattress typically lasts longer?

How long your mattress will last depends on the quality of materials that went into producing it. Firm mattresses usually hold up longer and better than soft ones. Because soft mattresses start out soft, they will usually sag or dip sooner than firm mattresses.

How much should I spend on a mattress?

How much you spend on a mattress will depend on several factors like the mattress brand, mattress size, and mattress type. Here is a breakdown of what you can expect to spend based on the size of your mattress:

  • Twin and Twin XL Mattresses: $400-$600
  • Full and Queen Mattresses: $600-$1,000
  • King and California King: $1,000-$2,000

Conclusion

Mattresses come in a range of different firmness levels, ensuring that one person’s most comfortable mattress will feel quite different from someone else’s. Each mattress firmness level comes with its own set of benefits. Whether a firmer or softer mattress is right for you will depend on your body type and sleeping position.

About the author
Amy Murphy

Amy Murphy has spent the last 7 years experimenting with different apps, exercises, products, and routines to optimize her sleep. From sleep tracking gadgets to polyphasic sleep schedules, she’s tried some of the most unusual recommendations for better shut-eye. As Best Mattress Brand’s lead tester, she’s reviewed dozens of different mattresses and bedding accessories to find her top recommendations. Through her articles, Amy shares the wealth of knowledge she has gained during these experiences so readers can find the best sleep possible.

Find more articles by Amy

Comments

Cancel reply

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Find the best mattress!

Best Mattress

Check out our mattress review guides to compare today's top-rated options and find your perfect mattress.

Explore our favorite beds

Popular Reads

What is the Biggest Bed Size?
Bennett Carrington
queen vs. california king
Queen vs. California King — What's the Difference?
Ashley Hooker
latex-vs-innerspring-mattress
Latex vs Innerspring Mattress — What’s the Difference?
Amy Murphy

Best Mattress Brand Fact-Checking Standards and Processes

The Best Mattress Brand writing team is devoted to creating articles that are not only entertaining and easy to understand but also as impartial, accurate, and well-sourced as possible. Whenever possible, we strive to have our articles fact-checked by our independent review board. We also do not tolerate plagiarism or ill intent from our contributors.

Here are the medical and factual guidelines that a Best Mattress Brand article must adhere to:

  • We draw upon only reputable and respectable sources when researching our articles’ topics and endeavor to only link to highly authoritative sources. Such sources would include peer-reviewed medical and academic journals, medical and academic associations in good standing, and interviews with or blog posts from certified medical professionals.
  • We may link to news articles or peer-reviewed medical blog posts about studies when appropriate, but always attempt to connect directly to the studies these pages discuss.
  • Our scientific information, conclusions, and analysis are always supported by at least one reputable source.
  • We strive to make any potential conflicts of interest attached to any studies or sources clear to our readers. When applicable, we also try to include conflicting research or questions that may throw a study’s conclusion into doubt to clarify that scientific understandings often change and progress over time.
  • Our articles typically link to other articles and resources on our site. This is solely for easier navigation, and we do not promote our website as a medical resource. Try to speak with your physician if you have medical concerns.
  • Any necessary background information on a topic will be included when appropriate.
  • Our goal is for every one of our medical-related articles to be reviewed by our independent board of experts. Should they spot any medical or health-related misinformation or errors, we will strike it out from the final published article.

What’s a Certified Sleep Coach?

Our authors have undergone sleep coach training from the Spencer Institute, becoming certified after immersing themselves in different aspects of sleep science. Understanding how we sleep means we understand better how a mattress, pillow, or other product can help us sleep better.

About Us

The Best Mattress Brand is a team of researchers and writers who are passionate about finding the perfect mattress for any situation.

Company

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclosure
  • Product Research Methodology

Our Guides

  • Mattresses
  • Best Mattresses of 2023
  • Adjustable Beds
  • Sleep Calculator
  • Mattress Sizes
  • Mattress Reviews
  • Mattress Resources
  • Bedding
  • Sleep Research

Newsletter

Subscribe to our monthly newsletter to find out about content, features and more happening at Best Mattress Brand.

You must enter a valid email.
Best Mattress Brand Logo

Copyright ©2023 Best Mattress Brand. All rights reserved.